FT calls Copenhagen Accord ‘dismal’, ‘fiasco’

December 21, 2009

Here’s the Copenhagen Accord.

The Financial Times blasted the non-agreement in today’s lead editorial, entitled “Dismal Outcome at Copenhagen Fiasco”:

An empty deal would be worse than no deal at all, said the White House before Mr Obama travelled to the Copenhagen summit. As the meeting ended, Barack Obama was calling the Copenhagen accord – the emptiest deal one could imagine, short of a fist fight – an “important breakthrough”. Mr Obama’s credibility at home and abroad is one casualty of this farcical outcome.

The agreement cobbled together by the US, China, India, Brazil and South Africa is merely an expression of aims. It recognises the scientific case for keeping the rise in global temperatures to 2°C. It calls on developed countries to provide $100bn a year in support of poor nations’ efforts by 2020, but without saying who pays what to whom. It appears to commit none of the signatories to anything.

Many developing countries were bitter about this result. Europe may wonder why it has been airbrushed out of the picture. The meeting as a whole could not bring itself to endorse this vacuous proclamation. It took note of it.

One wonders how a conference to conclude two years of detailed negotiations, building on more than a decade of previous talks, could have collapsed into such a shambles. It is as though no preparatory work had been done. Consensus on the most basic issues was lacking. Were countries there to negotiate binding limits on emissions or not? Nobody seemed to know.

From the start, the disarray was total. In this, at least, the attention to detail was impressive. The organisers invited more people to the event than could be accommodated, and were puzzled when they arrived. Delegates queued in the freezing cold for hours, a scene that summed it all up. The organisers had planned a celebration of a grand new global pact – but the party was a disaster and they forgot to bring the agreement.

Governments need to understand, even if they cannot say so, that Copenhagen was worse than useless. If you draw the world’s attention to an event of this kind, you have to deliver, otherwise the political impetus is lost. To declare what everybody knows to be a failure a success is feeble, and makes matters worse. Loss of momentum is now the danger. In future, governments must observe the golden rule of international co-operation: agree first, arrange celebrations and photo opportunities later…

3 Responses to “FT calls Copenhagen Accord ‘dismal’, ‘fiasco’”

  1. justbeau Says:

    Whereas the Wall Street Journal and other business oriented publications are finally waking up to the massive exaggeration and fraud that inflates trivial warming into a problem, the Financial Times and Economist have been purveyors of the Great Global Warming Hoax for years. Its disappointing. Maybe when Cameron gets into office, there can be a rigorous investigation of East Anglia and the British Met office.
    This could uncover more of the conspiracy of light-weight scientists to mislead and to infilrate Nature, the Royal Society, and other important institutions, and corrupt them with shoddy lies. An investigation in Britain can uncover more corruption by US government scientists too.

  2. Bob Says:

    We should be very disappointed that the great minds of the earth were once again prevented from demonstrating that they can control the climate.

  3. dublds Says:

    Amazing that the FT laments that no binding global pact was signed by the same people who proved utterly incompetent at even putting together a one week event.

    Sure, let’s let the people who can’t properly manage 40000 visitors for a week, write legislation that binds 6 billion people for 100 years. Great idea.

    “Oooooh, what a missed opportunity…”

    The FT should change their name from the Financial Times to the “Fuckin’ ‘Tards”.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: